Urgent Open Letter

They affect individuals – but they are intended for all of us.

They were never gone: One of the most consequential practices of injustice of political exclusion and political persecution in the Federal Republic of Germany is currently experiencing a revival: the employment ban also internationally known as “Berufsverbot”. This revival manifests itself, among other things, in Hamburg’s Parliament’s decision to reintroduce routing inquiries

 This can be seen, among other things, in the decision of the Hamburg Parliament to effectively reintroduce routine inquiries (Regelanfragen) to the intelligence services (Verfassungsschutz). Under the pretext of protecting democracy from „extremism,“ a growing number of people are being scrutinized for state loyalty. Those affected are often young career entrants, students, many teachers, scientists, and public-sector employees.

It is a practice that hardly any other European country applies in this form: anyone who demonstrates, organizes in trade unions, publishes in critical media, or engages in anti-fascist, peace, climate, or social activism can just as easily come into the focus of state investigations as people who are allegedly members of all kinds of organizations. Consequently, they face denied hiring, disciplinary proceedings, or exclusion from their profession. Acting both as supreme judge and prosecutor are the democratically opaque, completely illegitimate, uncontrollable intelligence services, Verfassungsschutz, which were involved in fascist murder series such as the NSU.

The history of the Federal Republic shows that employment bans have always served one purpose above all: the political disciplining of the societal Left. The Radical Decree of 1972 (Radikalenerlass) already led to millions of screenings and thousands of proceedings against predominantly left-wing employees and applicants. Cases on the political Right have historically been rare, even though employment bans against right-wing extremists are currently occurring in some instances. It is safe to assume that the historical pattern will repeat itself: on the side of the political Left, among others, teacher Lisa Poettinger, IT specialist Ahmad Othman, and lawyer Melanie Schweizer are forced to fight for their professional futures. And although the case of Alruna Hauser — the daughter of fascist Kubitschek barred from teaching  — testifies to employment bans against the political Right, further cases point to historical continuities: a right-wing extremist of the Identitarian Movement remains in the legal traineeship of the Passau Regional Court, and right-wing extremist police officers remain in office despite „Heil Hitler“ messages and KZ fantasies.

However, it would be a mistake to call for employment bans against political opponents ourselves. Fascists have no place in a democratic society — but employment bans are the tactically wrong instrument and threaten, as a repressive boomerang, to ultimately strike the societal Left. Today we find ourselves at the beginning of a new wave of political investigations and disciplinary proceedings. Their full scope is only slowly becoming apparent — it could far exceed the circle of those affected by the historical Radical Decree. „Terrorist,“ „close to Hamas,“ „climate gluer (Klimakleber)“ — extended notions around security or threats increasingly enable sweeping state-surveillance measures in combination with Artificial Intelligence.

Yet employment bans never affect only those directly targeted: they are meant to deter.

Punish one — discipline hundreds: a traditional motto.

But especially during times of growing social inequality, massive militarization, increasing authoritarian tendencies, and the preparation of a resistance-free „home front,“ exactly the opposite is needed: critical science, strong trade unions, vibrant social movements, and open democratic debate. Fundamental rights lose their value if they only apply as long as they do not produce fundamental criticism of existing conditions. Employment bans are, thus, not an individual problem of individually affected persons. They are an expression of societal power relations. Ultimately, they also fundamentally attack all forms of collective organization: the DGB (unions), parties, a free press, and NGOs.

Isolation and withdrawal into privacy have always been among the most effective instruments of state repression. Our only possible answer is collective organizing.

Our Demands

• Abolish employment bans completely.

• Immediately halt all ongoing employment ban proceedings.

• Rehabilitate and financially compensate those affected.

• Dissolve the Verfassungsschutz.

• Expand political fundamental rights instead of controlling convictions.

We call on the state governments of Hamburg, Rhineland-Palatinate, North Rhine-Westphalia, Brandenburg, and Bavaria to withdraw their current plans without delay, or to repeal existing regulations. At the same time, we appeal to all other federal states not to introduce comparable measures. Likewise, we demand the termination of all ongoing proceedings, the reinstatement or adequate employment of those affected, and their political and material rehabilitation.

Why We Are Organizing

Legal proceedings and well-sounding appeals on their own will not stop this development. Employment bans are not an administrative problem, but a political weapon. That is why we want to connect those affected with one another, document experiences, create publicity, and organize solidarity in practical terms. We want to bring together trade unions, universities, students, academics, employees, and all democratic forces who refuse to accept the dismantling of democratic rights — across the boundaries of all democratic parties, trade unions, and civil organizations.

Who We Are

We are an initiative against political employment bans, formed out of a growing circle of people who are themselves affected, currently face proceedings or have faced them, or explicitly declare solidarity with those affected. What unites us is the conviction that democratic rights are indivisible and that political convictions must never determine whether people can exercise their profession. We come from trade unions, social movements, and civil society, with different party-political affiliations. What unites us is the goal of countering the normalization of political repression — of halting the renaissance of employment ban practices.

We understand ourselves as anti-fascist, in solidarity with Palestine, and internationalist, with a majority also identifying as anti-capitalist. We stand for a society in which political criticism is not sanctioned but understood as a necessary component of democratic development — and in which a domestic intelligence agency does not decide over professional existences, courts do not submissively follow, and participants are not silenced.

Democratic rights were never given — they were fought for. And they will only persist if we defend them together.